| AED3 | HeartStart Onsite | AEDPlus | PowerHeart G5 | |
| Manufacturer | Zoll | Philips | Zoll | Cardiac Science |
| SJA Retail Price | $1,980.00 | $1,498.00 | $1,710.00 | $1,999.00 |
| Price Includes: | ||||
| Owner's Manual | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Quick Reference Guide | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| AED Adult Pads (no CPR feedback) | 0 | 2 sets | 0 | 1 set |
| AED Adult Pads (with CPR Feedback) | 1 set | 0 | 1 set | 1 set |
| Battery | 1 battery pack | 1 battery pack | 10 individual batteries | 1 battery pack |
| Standard Carrying Case | No | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Fast Response Kit (gloves, pocket mask, scissors, razor, wipe) | Gloves, face shield, scissors, razor, wipe in a package attached to pad | Yes | Gloves, face shield, scissors, razor, wipe in a package attached to pad | Yes |
| Alarmed Wall Cabinet | Available for purchase | Available for purchase | Available for purchase | Included |
| Warranty | ||||
| Warranty | 6-year | 8-year | 7-year | 8-year |
| Battery | Inserted Battery | Inserted Battery | Inserted batteries | Inserted Battery |
| Shelf-Life (Not in Unit) | data not available | 5 years | data not available | Operational Guaranteed |
| Stand-By Life (in Unit) | 3 years (auto self test report on) to 5 years (auto self test report off) | 4 years | 5 years | 4 years |
| Battery Capacity | 30 shocks; 2 hours 20 minutes | 200 shocks; 4 hours | 225 Shocks | 420 Shocks |
| Battery Price | $205 | $164 | $105 | $395 |
| 30-Day Warning To Replace Battery | No | No | No | Yes |
| AED Pad/Electrode Life | 5 years | 2 years | 5 years | 2 years |
| AED Pad Price | $225 | $62 | $190 | $79 (no feedback) $242 (with feedback) |
| 30-Day Warning To Replace Pads | No | No | No | Yes |
| Technical Specifications | ||||
| Height | 9.3 Inches (23.6cm) | 7.4 Inches (18.8cm) | 11.5 Inches (29.2cm) | 11 Inches (30cm) |
| Width | 9.7 Inches (24.7cm) | 8.3 Inches (21.1cm) | 9.5 Inches (24.1cm) | 9 Inches (23cm) |
| Depth | 5 Inches (12.7cm) | 2.8 Inches (7.1cm) | 5.25 Inches (13.3cm) | 3.4 Inches (9cm) |
| Weight (with battery and pads) | 5.5 lbs. (2.5kg) | 3.3 lbs. (1.5kg) | 6.7 lbs. (3.1kg) | 5.7 lbs. (2.6kg) |
| Operating Temperature | 32 to 122F (0 to 50C) | 33 to 122F (0 to 50C) | 34 to 122F (0 to 50C) | 35 to 122F (0 to 50C) |
| Storage Temperature | -22-158F (-30 to 70C) | |||
| Altitude | - 1,250 ft to 15,000 ft | 0 to 15,000ft | -300 to 15,000ft | - 1,253 ft to 15,073 ft |
| Ingress Protection (against dust & water) | IP55 | IP21 | IP55 | IP55 |
| Falling Height | 1 metre | 1 metre | no data from manufacturer | 2 metre |
| Features | ||||
| CPR Coaching | Yes | Push Button to activate | Yes | Customizable for basic, intermediate, and professional rescuers |
| Metronome for CPR Compression | Varies from 103 to 107 beats per minute | 100 beats per minute | Varies from 60 to 100 beats per minute | 100 beats per minute |
| Text Screen | LCD Touchscreen | No | Displays rescue prompts and critical information | Display rescue prompts and critical rescue information |
| Semi-Automated (push button to shock patient) |
Fully Automatic (no need to push button to shock) also available | Yes | Fully Automatic (no need to push button to shock) also available | Fully Automatic (no need to push button to shock) also available |
| Escalating Energy | Low to Medium to High range | No | Low to Medium to High | Low to Medium to High range |
| Therapy Range | Fixed | Fixed | Fixed | Variable (based on casualty's size) |
| Energy Delivered - Adult | 120 J to 200 J | 150 J | 120 J to 200 J | 95 J to 354 J |
| Energy Delivered - Infant/Child | 50 J to 85 J | 50 J | 50 J to 85 J | 22J to 82 J |
| Shock Delivery | 10 seconds or less | 8 seconds | 10 seconds or less with new batteries | 10 seconds or less |
| CPR Feedback device | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Visible Indicators | Readiness, time, number of shocks | Readiness Only | Readiness, time, number of shocks | Readiness, battery, service, time, number of shocks and pad status |
| Languages Available | English or French models | English or French models | English or French models | English, French or Dual Language models |
| Automated Self Test | Weekly, Monthly | Daily, weekly, monthly | Weekly, Monthly | Daily, weekly, monthly |
| Functionality Test | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Battery Insertion Test | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Pad Integrity Test | No | Yes | No | Yes |
| Energy Charge Cycle Test | Monthly full test | Weekly partial test; Monthly full test | Monthly full test | Weekly partial test; Monthly full test |
| Self Test Report over WiFi | Yes | IR download only | IR download only | USB download only |
| Rescue Data Storage | 20 minutes | 15 minutes | 50 minutes | 90 minutes |
| Data Transmission | USB or WiFi | InfraRed Wireless ($188 for IR-USB adapter) | IR | USB cable or memory key |
| Data Analysis | Software available through cloud-based system | $415 for software (single PC license) | Software Included | Software Included |
| Extra Items | ||||
| Pediatric (Child/Infant) Pads | Not Required | $100 | $150 | Non-Polarized ($127.50) |
| Wall Cabinet with Alarm | $250 | $243 | $250 | $249 |
Technical Information for and Comparison of Zoll AED 3, Zoll AEDPlus, Philips Onsite, and Cardiac Science G5 Print
Modified on: Tue, Jan 16, 2018 at 2:48 PM
Did you find it helpful? Yes No
Send feedbackSorry we couldn't be helpful. Help us improve this article with your feedback.